So i am part of two in person writing groups and two online groups. I have turned in the same piece of work to all four groups as sort of a test and got wildly different feedback as to what they “suggest”. One will say more X and less Y where the next person will say the complete opposite. I am perplexed to put it mildly. Now i am also reviewing their works at the same time and so have listening more so to those “i deem” to be better writers than those that leave me mentally  contorted.

What to do?